Points |
Physical Gold |
Gold ETF |
Sovereign Gold Bonds |
What are they? |
Physical Gold are usually purchased
in the form of bars, jewels, and coins. |
ETF is similar to a mutual fund, AMC hold the assets and charges a maintenance fee for the same. They can be bought and sold through stock exchanges. | SGB are government bonds that are
held in the books of RBI and in Demat Form. Thus, making it free of any
charge. |
Regulator |
Nil |
SEBI |
RBI |
Purchase Mode |
From Jewellers |
From Stock Exchange |
From Banks and Financial Institutions |
Purity of Gold |
Purity of Gold always remains a
question |
High |
High |
Investment Limit |
No Cap |
No Cap |
Investment Up to 4 KG by Individuals,
HUF and 20 Kg by Trust in a Financial Year |
Income |
Appreciation in Gold Price |
Appreciation in Gold Price |
2.5% Interest on Initial Investment
and Appreciation in Gold Price |
Returns |
Lower than actual return on gold |
Lower than actual return on Gold |
Higher than actual return on gold |
Safety |
Risk on handling physical gold. |
Highly Safe |
Highly Safe |
Short Term Capital Gain |
Taxable as per Income Slab |
Taxable as per Income Slab |
Taxable as per Income Slab |
Long Term Capital Gain |
Long term capital gain tax applicable
after 3 years at 20% With Indexation |
Long term capital gain tax applicable
after 3 years at 20% With Indexation |
No Capital Gain Tax if held till
maturity |
Collateral against Loan |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
Tradability / Exit Route |
Conditional Sale |
Tradable on Exchange |
Tradable on Exchange and Redemption
5th year onwards with Government of India |
Storage Cost |
High |
Nil |
Nil |
SGB Beats the Physical Gold and ETF by fair margin in terms of returns, safety and liquidity. Mentotax recommends to Stick to SGB for Portfolio diversification, Asset class diversification and high post tax return.